Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Nature and Nurture: The Importance of Motherhood in Zofloya, or The Moor

Charlotte Dacre's 1806 novel begins not with the eponymous Zofloya or his tempestuous lover Victoria di Loredani, but with the corruption and seduction of Victoria’s mother, acknowledging the novel’s interest in parental responsibility on childhood development.  Similar to Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights, Dacre creates a generational gap in her narrative to show how paternal and maternal influences, or lack thereof, affect the outcome of the second generation.  Both Bronte and Dacre’s characters, despite their aristocratic class, become wild and impassionate through the negative presence of the mother.  Dacre’s somewhat psychological approach to the novel allows for both male and female characters to employ manipulation and power for pleasure, a radical depiction of female authority at the time.


The novel expresses the difficulty in successfully raising children, especially for the nobility, focusing on the limitless flow of pleasure that wealth affords them.  Though the Marchese and his wife are innocent in their endeavors to make their children happy, Leonardo and Victoria turn out spoilt and in constant need of pleasure.  Victoria develops “a wild, ardent, and irrepressible spirit, indifferent to reproof, careless of censure –of an implacable, revengeful, and cruel nature” (4) while Leonardo, “with all the bolder shades of her character…[develops] a warm impassioned soul, yielding easily to the seductions of the wild and beautiful, accessible of temptation, and unable to resist, in any shape, the first impulses of his heart” (4).  Even under the guidance of a stable matriarch the children develop a wanting disposition that takes shape after their mother leaves with Ardolph.  Laurina becomes taken by the affections of Ardolph, and her vanity and weak nature are unable to resist his bold profession.  She is torn “with conflicting sentiments; her reason, her gratitude, the secret and powerful ties of early habit, taught her to adore her husband; but the insidious Ardolph daily led her senses wandering, and corrupted the purity of her heart” (11).  The danger of passion resonates throughout the novel, and holding multiple passions simultaneously seems to allude to an unsafe division of the mind.  Laurina’s marriage to the Marchese was founded in a youthful “delirium of passion,” and her attraction to Ardolph is likewise fueled by passion and vanity.

After her mother’s abandonment of the pallazzo, Victoria becomes the matriarch of the home, a position she is clearly not prepared for or even aware of.  Without her mother’s reproofs, Victoria’s spirit, now “with an unlimited scope for the growth of [her] dangerous propensities…bade fair soon to overtop the power of restriction” (14).  Though her father believes that, despite her always having a corrupt nature, a proper education will tame Victoria’s more wild and passionate characteristics, her mother essentially “seals the fiat of [her] future destruction, by setting [Victoria] in her own conduct an example of moral depravity” (15).  The successful cultivation of a child thus seems, according to Dacre, a combination of nature, nurture, education, and maternal influence.  Victoria’s lack of all these qualities prepares the reader for the remainder of the plot, and even her father, upon realizing the extent of her character, “endeavored to disguise from himself the suspicion that her heart was evil” (15).

 That Victoria is exposed to the relationship between Ardolph and Laurina after the death of her father further distorts her understanding of the role of the matriarch.  Though Laurina promises to her husband to correct her mistakes toward Victoria, she falls again into the hands of her murderous lover Ardolph, this time bringing Victoria with her.  Her mother defies every oath she has taken, resisting the role of a wife, a mother, even a woman, and through this Victoria develops "an ardent consuming desire to be situated like that unhappy mother...such were the baleful effects of parental vice upon the mind of a daughter" (28).  Though she becomes attached to the Il Conte Berenza, her condemnation of her mother warns Berenza to her cruel nature and he becomes cautious of his love for her.

Laurina's reckless influence on her daughter confirms Victoria's wicked nature throughout the novel, expressing Dacre's opinions on the role of the mother in developing the behaviors of her child.  By denying the sanctity of motherhood, Dacre's female characters circumvent any stereotypical categorization of femininity.

For a general overview of the nature/nurture debate, click here.

To what extent does the role of the mother influence the actions of Victoria and Leonardo? 

How are the traditional standards of women challenged, especially through motherhood and matrimony, and does this reveal anything about the female nature? 


No comments:

Post a Comment